Can investment trusts save income investors?

The cut to that dividend in April this year was a watershed moment, ending an unbroken record stretching back to the Second World War and shaking the confidence of income investors.

Shell wasn’t alone.

UK dividends fell by 54 per cent between April and June compared to the same period of last year, while global dividends are forecast to be between 17 per cent and 23 per cent lower in 2020 due to the pandemic, according to the Janus Henderson Global Dividend Index. 

These dividend cuts have a real-life impact, as recent research by the Association of Investment Companies (AIC) bears out. 

More than one in six investors has already had to change their plans or lifestyle as a result of loss of income.

Of these, 63 per cent have cut back on non-essential items or activities, 39 per cent have cancelled or changed holiday plans for financial reasons and 19 per cent have pushed back their hoped-for retirement date.

One investor commented: “This could be the new normal couldn’t it? The nice 5 per cent or 6 per cent or 7 per cent dividends that you get from some companies, maybe that is never coming again. It could kill it off, so that is a worry for the future definitely.”

But one category of income investors seemed more confident about the future. These were investors in investment companies (investment trusts). 

While only 11 per cent of non-investment company investors were “not at all concerned” about loss of income, that increased to 21 per cent among investment company users and 37 per cent among those who held the majority of their portfolio in investment companies.

AIC survey result (below) after asking income investors: What changes have you made to your plans/lifestyle in response to dividend cuts?

Source: AIC/Research in finance (fieldwork 31 July 2020 to 22 August 2020)

Lower levels of anxiety among investment company investors reflect some differences in the structure of investment companies that enable them to deliver more reliable income, or higher levels of income.

More than one in six investors has already had to change their plans or lifestyle as a result of loss of income.

Separate AIC research suggests these differences are not well known or understood by advisers or the investing public. 

Dividend smoothing and the revenue reserve

The first important structural difference is the ‘revenue reserve’, a feature of investment companies that allows them to hold back up to 15 per cent of the income they receive in any year from their investments, and save it for distribution in future years.