Jeff Prestridge 

Insurers fleecing loyal customers

Jeff Prestridge

Jeff Prestridge

Product commoditisation is now endemic across financial services. Like knotweed, it spreads everywhere and it does nothing but harm.

I see evidence of this unwelcome trait every day of my working life as readers regularly contact me annoyed that their loyalty has been abused by their insurer (usually) or other financial product provider.

This manifests itself in car or home insurance premiums higher than those if they approached their insurer afresh as a new customer. Or in premiums that are far more expensive than equivalent cover offered elsewhere, usually through a comparison website. Perversely, the more loyal they are, the more financially disadvantaged they become.

Of course this is outrageous, but no one – other than angry consumers – seems to want to change the status quo. Insurers are happy to fleece long-standing customers rather than reward them for their loyalty. More one-year stand than a relationship for life. Shameful.

OK, Aviva boss Mark Wilson – “Mr Rent-a-Quote” – keeps promising to look at the issue (a pilot is in progress which looks at how long-standing customers might get better treatment), but I am not hopeful. Indeed, Aviva is as parasitic as the rest, evidenced by the trick it has just pulled on some of its health insurance customers. It has been busy hiking premiums for customers who pay for Healthier Solutions cover annually rather than by monthly instalment.

The hike, it says, is to remove the “discount” that immediate payers enjoy over regular payers. What utter garbage. It is the regular payers who quite rightly pay a premium for getting 12 months to pay for the cover they receive immediately. A decent insurer would have removed this premium rather than hit annual payers with a price hike. 

Of course, Mr Wilson has hungry income-obsessed shareholders to appease. Profit before customers. Profit before loyalty.

The regulator’s answer to the shenanigans of the insurers is to ensure people are prompted to shop around – by being given details at renewal of their existing premium and the new quote. It seems to have concluded that insurance is a commodity product and customer loyalty is a factor it should not take into account when laying down the rules insurers should obey.

Revenue from comparisons

Comparison websites are happy for commoditisation to thrive. After all it is in their financial best interests. The more switching there is, the more revenue they generate.

There are small pockets of the financial services industry where loyalty is still valued. A handful of building societies reward long-standing customers with special one-off deals or discounts and they seem to be benefiting from such a stance – the likes of Nationwide and Coventry.

The value of loyalty shines brightest in the world of independent financial advice. Individuals who are looked after by a financial adviser long term reap the greatest benefit. I have been saying this for years, but it has been difficult to quantify the benefit, other than by the odd case study. Thankfully we now have the evidence.