Why bother with a pension?
I've been asked this question by friends and family nearly every week since I first started working as a financial journalist back in 1999.
In fact, even before then, I was helping to put myself through university by working in a local authority pensions department.
I've always been an advocate of the workplace pension - where else can you get a minimum of 100 per cent return on your investment? I put in £1, my employer puts in £1. Actually, I put in 6 per cent of my salary before tax, my employer currently puts in 12 per cent. That's pretty generous.
Ever since I started work, I've paid as much as the scheme rules allow into a pension pot. Granted, I started off on a salary of £16,000 and 20 years on I'm only just about doubling that salary, but even so, I've accumulated about £60,000 in various pots.
But I am starting to wonder myself whether it is worth it. I got my pension statement through from the defined contribution pension I paid into from 1 April 2010 (an inauspicious date) to December 2015.
It claimed I had £45,000 or so, with an expected £60,000 something when I reach scheme retirement age.
According to the projections, this would mean I could enjoy the wondrous taxable income of £1,200 a year.
More accurately, £1,284 a year.
One thousand, two hundred and eighty four pounds a year. Before tax.
Let me put this into perspective. That's less than £100 a month. And that's before I get old enough to have free TV licences and winter fuel allowances (if these even exist when I retire).
I showed this to my mother, who used to work for the Guardian Royal Exchange, then Prudential, then Hartshead pensions. She retired on £16,000 and thanks to a generous GAR, she actually enjoys a higher annual income from her workplace pension than I am expected to do.
Diligence is not being rewarded. What happens to my £1,280 if there's another 'lost decade' like there was in 2008? How can I recover from any market risk?
Even assuming that all my collective pots get me about £80,000 when I retire, we're looking at maybe £2,400 a year.
Evidently I can't afford to divorce my husband, so that's not an option, even if I wanted to, which I don't. It's only been four dewy-eyed years, after all.
We still have a mortgage but even if we do succeed in paying that off in the next 10 years, what's a few thousand going to get us for our prudence in saving? I'll have to start using the foodbank that my husband and I run.
Many years ago I was interviewed by someone at the Mail and I argued the toss with him about pensions. I staunchly defended pensions; he advocated Isas. Needless to say I didn't back down, nor did I get the job.