Defined Benefit  

Getting used to how advising on pension transfers is now done

  • Being brought up to date with the latest thinking on DB transfers
  • Understanding the importance of APTA and TVC
  • Learning how the advice process on DB transfers has changed
Getting used to how advising on pension transfers is now done

In late March of this year the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) published its much-awaited Policy Statement (PS18/6) detailing the new safeguards it requires of all parties involved in the defined benefit (DB) transfers market, following a nine-month review of the market and intense parliamentary pressure from MP Frank Field’s work and pensions select committee. 

There are two clear and powerful drivers stimulating increased DB to defined contribution (DC) transfers that have risen close to 100,000 a year from less than half that number in 2016. The first is the eye-poppingly high transfer values being offered by employers to DB scheme holders. Transfer values are often 25 to 30 times the value of the annual pension that the occupational pension had promised – a life-changing amount of money for many. 

However, it is not just the amounts of money on offer but the potential for immediate access to these sums – the arrival of 'pension freedoms' three years ago offered the potential to transfer all this money (minus charges) into a DC scheme, thereby opening up a range of decumulation options for over-55 year olds, by far the most popular of which is to take all pension assets out in one go (after tax of course). 

Another reason why transfer requests are on the up, from our own research into baby boomer decumulation decision-making, is that increasing numbers of people are experiencing career shocks in their 50s. Many have been made redundant from well-paid senior positions and been forced into lower-paying positions offering less income security. Others have simply opted for more flexible, part-time working arrangements later in their working lives. 

There is a clear attraction to getting the funds across to a more understandable benefit structure, even if you do not take all the money out straight away. And, what with the job shocks that many have experienced, they may even need to access some of that money from age 55 while remaining money can be moved into an array of decumulation orientated policies. Even if the DB scheme allows early retirement, it will not allow the benefits to be segmented in this way.

After discovering in its October 2015 Thematic Review that only 47 per cent of the transfer cases it reviewed adequately demonstrated suitability, the FCA fixed on hammering out and imposing new requirement on pension transfer specialists, providers and advisers, together designed to safeguard an increasing number of DB holders requesting transfer valuations. 

The scope for customer detriment is of course very significant when transferring out of DB schemes as consumers risk giving up extremely valuable (percentage of final or average salary-based) retirement income guarantees and other difficult and expensive to replicate employer covenants. That customer detriment can quickly turn to adviser detriment if their recommendations were not fully compliant and relevant, detailed records were not filed away securely.

We now know the bulk of the changes, laid out in the Policy Statement, centre on a new transfer value comparator (TVC), sitting within a highly-comprehensive appropriate pensions transfer analysis (APTA) report. Both need to be in place by 1 October this year. Other changes are effective from the start of this month.


Please answer the six multiple choice questions below in order to bank your CPD. Multiple attempts are available until all questions are correctly answered.

  1. According to Adrian Boulding, which of the following is a significant reason for DB transfer requests being on the increase?

  2. According to Adrian Boulding, what is the ultimate aim of the Transfer Value Comparator?

  3. The FCA is a great believer in critical yield calculations, true or false?

  4. According to Adrian Boulding, what has been the real 'game changer' in DB transfers?

  5. According to Adrian Boulding, advisers are not held liable for advice when the advice is checked by a third-party pension transfer specialist. True or false?

  6. Which of the following will make life more expensive for advisers

Nearly There…

You have successfully answered all the questions correctly, well done!

You should now know…

  • Being brought up to date with the latest thinking on DB transfers
  • Understanding the importance of APTA and TVC
  • Learning how the advice process on DB transfers has changed

I completed this CPD in

To bank your CPD please complete the form below.

Were the stated learning objectives met?

Why weren't they met?

What did you learn from undertaking this CPD exercise?

Why did you undertake this piece of learning?


Congratulations, you have successfully completed and banked this piece of CPD

Already Banked!

You have already banked for this article.

To bank your CPD you must or


One or more questions have been incorrectly answered,
 please review your answers and try again.

Please complete all the above text fields to bank your CPD.

More Pensions CPDSee my completed CPDSee all CPD