Talking PointJun 29 2018

Research suggests women are better savers than men

twitter-iconfacebook-iconlinkedin-iconmail-iconprint-icon
Search supported by
Research suggests women are better savers than men

This is according to research from Nest Insight and Vanguard published in a report titled How the UK Saves.

The study, which analyses the choices, demographics, behaviours and likely outcomes of the nearly 6.5 million members of the workplace pension scheme, showed that the median savings balance for females (£174) in the master trust is 76 per cent of the median balance for males (£228).

However, after adjusting for earnings, women have higher median contributions and higher median account balances in all but the highest earnings band, where the difference was negligible, the report stated.

For workers earning between £10,000 and £14,999 annually, female median contributions and account balances were 26 and 20 per cent greater than males, respectively.

William Allport, senior retirement strategist at Vanguard and one of the authors of the study, argued that “after controlling for earnings, women appear to be saving more than men, within the Nest arrangement”.

He said: “It’s a very interesting finding, and a subject we’ll be researching further.”

Several pensions experts have told FTAdviser this research sheds new light on the impact of pay inequality on pensions.

Jessica List, pensions technical manager at Curtis Banks, argued the fact that women are saving more as a percentage of their earnings but still achieving lower balances than men shows the effect the gender pay gap is having.

Rachel Vahey, product technical manager at Nucleus, claimed that it is vital the UK continues its drive to address the gender pay gap, and as this begins to narrow the pension savings made by women should increase.

She said: “This research shows women already have the savings habit, and that is an important part of the battle to increase savings in the UK.”

Kate Smith, head of pensions at Aegon, agreed that gender pay inequality is the main cause of the pension savings gender gap adding "women earn less so they save less”.

She said: “This widens with age, compounded by women disrupted working patterns.

“And it’s not helped by auto-enrolment, which disproportionately excludes more women than men from workplace pensions due to low earnings.”

Ms Smith argued, however, that people shouldn’t be carried away by Nest’s research results, as the scheme “focuses on average to low earners and isn’t representative of the whole of the market.”

Recent analysis from Aegon showed the gap between men and women’s saving pots grows dramatically with age, and will result in women being considerably worse off in retirement.

A survey conducted by Prudential showed that women’s expected retirement income has hit a record high, but they will still have an average retirement income £4,900 lower than men if they retire this year.

Romi Savova, chief executive of fintech provider PensionBee, noted that it “is encouraging to see women taking action to close the gap through additional contributions, suggesting women are better savers”.

She said: “However, at a societal level, the data clearly shows that closing the pay gap is key to putting women on an equal footing with their male counterparts.

“If companies don’t step up to equalise pay at every level of seniority, the pay gap will have a life-lasting impact on British women well through retirement.”

For Kay Ingram, director of public policy at national firm LEBC, the fact that women appear to be better savers then man “may reflect the self-realisation that more women expect to have gaps in their careers, due to taking on caring responsibilities later on, and so are keener to save more from current earnings than men”.

She said: “Men may have a greater expectation of rising career earnings, and so are more comfortable putting off some saving now, in anticipation of future saving opportunities.

“However, this view may be mistaken as it ignores the benefits of compounding savings over the longer term coupled with the benefits of pound cost averaging investment over a longer period.”

Gem Durham, independent financial adviser at Obsidian, argues that it isn’t “necessary or helpful to say one sex is the better saver”.

She said: “I’m not sure it’s true. Having a good attitude to saving is in part about understanding and appreciating deferred gratification, I know many men and women who are good at this and many men and women who are terrible! 

“It’s also about understanding the value of the saving – you need to know why the deferred gratification is worth it.

“Auto-enrolment is a great idea, but if we really want a nation of savers we need to start educating at school and getting parents involved too.”

maria.espadinha@ft.com