Automatic enrolment  

Regulator receives 114 whistleblowing reports about AE

Regulator receives 114 whistleblowing reports about AE

The Pensions Regulator (TPR) has received 114 whistleblowing reports about employers allegedly inducing employees to opt out of auto-enrolment pension schemes in the past three years.

According to a Freedom of Information request published on the watchdog’s website, the majority (99) concerned allegations of inducement while the remaining 15 were about allegations of inducement along with other breaches. 

The number of reports received have increased over the years – between April 2015 and March 2016 the regulator received 12 complaints, which rose to 38 in 2016/17, and 64 in 2017/18.

Article continues after advert

These numbers could increase even further, as Darren Ryder, TPR’s director of automatic enrolment, said in May the watchdog was receiving more than 80 reports every week from people who suspected employers were breaking the law on workplace pensions.

A spokesperson at TPR said the regulator took the issue of inducement "very seriously" but did not have evidence to suggest there was a widespread issue of employers attempting to induce workers to opt out of automatic enrolment.

She said: "The number of whistleblowing reports we have received must be taken in the context that more than 1.3 million employers have completed their declaration of compliance – almost all of them in the last three years - as automatic enrolment has expanded.

"Nevertheless, we would encourage any workers who are not being given the pensions they are entitled to, or who believe their employers are committing pensions offences, to contact us and we will investigate.

"Automatic enrolment is not an option, it’s the law. We will take action against employers who fail to comply with it."

Malcolm McLean, senior consultant at Barnett Waddingham, said that he isn't "especially surprised" that the numbers of whistleblowing reports have increased as the roll out of auto-enrolment has progressed.

He said: "Many employers particularly the smaller ones were known to be concerned about the increased costs auto-enrolling their workers would incur for them, and would be tempted to find ways of influencing their employees to opt out. 

"The reports may actually understate the true extent of the numbers and could even be the tip of the iceberg, although I have no means of knowing that for certain. 

"Whether the regulator did enough to warn employers about the potential consequences of their actions in this respect is debatable and it should seriously consider even at this stage doing and saying more to discourage it."

The most recent case involving a whistleblower was a healthcare company in Birmingham, whose staff were told that pension contributions were being paid by the employer when, in fact, a scheme hadn't even been set up.

Crest Healthcare managing director Sheila Aluko was fined more than £20,000 after admitting misleading the regulator and failing to comply with auto-enrolment duties.

TPR had prosecuted a company for inducement for the first time this year.

Senior staff at Workchain, a national recruitment agency, impersonated their temporary workers to opt them out of their workplace pension scheme.