Scottish WidowsJan 30 2019

Scottish Widows accused of poaching IFA clients

twitter-iconfacebook-iconlinkedin-iconmail-iconprint-icon
Search supported by
Scottish Widows accused of poaching IFA clients

Scottish Widows has been accused of trying to poach an IFA's client with a letter promoting the provider's own advisers.

Scott Gallacher, IFA and director of Rowley Turton Private Wealth Management, was outraged when one of his clients received a letter from Scottish Widows suggesting the provider's "fully qualified and authorised financial advisers" could help him.

The letter, dated January 24, was sent to Mr Gallacher's client by Robert Kerr, head of Scottish Widows Direct.

The letter stated: "Since setting up your Scottish Widows pension there have been significant changes within the pensions industry largely driven by regulatory change.

"One example of this was the 'Pension Freedoms' legislation. As a result of this, there are certain Scottish Widows clients with older Pension Plans who we feel may benefit from lower charges in a newer style plan, and/or may be in a better position to take advantage of the new 'Pensions Freedoms' legislation.

"We strongly recommend that all clients regularly review their policies to ensure they remain appropriate and in line with your overall retirement plans.

"Scottish Widows can assist you with this by offering the services of our fully qualified and authorised Financial Advisers.

"They will carry out a detailed analysis and review of your retirement provision with no obligation from you to proceed with any recommendation."

The letter then stated if the customer already has an IFA, they should contact them in the first instance or visit www.unbiased.co.uk to find an adviser.

However, Mr Kerr ends the letter stating: "I do hope you will undertake the review and analysis and look forward to receiving your reply slip."

The recipient of the letter was also provided with a form, attached to the letter, which they could fill in and return in a pre-paid envelope if they wanted to take up the offer to use Scottish Widows' own adviser.

The letter has infuriated Mr Gallacher who views it as a "blatant attempt" to poach his clients.

He said his client, who he set up with a Scottish Widows pension 15 years ago, sent him the letter after it made him concerned he needed to seek new advice about his pension policy.

Mr Gallacher said: "I've had this client for 20 years. Scottish Widows is biting the hand that feeds them by sending this letter.

"To me, it seems they are trying to cut advisers out of the loop. It is not standard practice for pension providers to do this, or at least it shouldn't be.

"Providers know there is almost always an ongoing financial adviser relationship already in place, where the provider has paid us a commission.

"So why is the head of Scottish Widows Direct sending this letter to my client?"

Mr Gallacher added the letter has left him frustrated as it breaks the trust between adviser and provider.

He said: "We introduced these clients to Scottish Widows, and now it seems they are trying to take the client from us.

"It makes you question what else they might fail to honour or what they might sacrifice just for short-term gain?"

But a spokesman for Scottish Widows said the provider had always recommended that customers seek financial advice before making decisions on their finances.

The spokesman said: "[We] explain that customers who already have an IFA should contact him or her in the first instance, which has happened in this case as a result of the letter.

"Not all customers will have an IFA, so we share a number of ways they can find a suitably qualified one, including via Unbiased, to allow them to make an informed decision that best suits their needs."

Alan Chan, IFA and director of IFS Wealth & Pensions, said Scottish Widows should know which clients already have an adviser and which do not and send out appropriate letters to suit each customer.

Mr Chan said: "I've not seen such a letter or had any clients make me aware of this.

"If it was sent to advised clients too, I would be very unhappy with Scottish Widows.

"I can understand that it is a one-size-fits-all templated letter to all personal pension clients, advised or direct, but they should know which clients have IFAs and which do not.

"So if they are urging clients who already have an IFA to review their pensions, they should just encourage them to contact their adviser directly and have removed that paragraph about using Scottish Widow's own, restricted, advisers.

"Talk about biting the hand that feeds them."

Dippy Singh is a freelance journalist