Firefighters prepare fresh legal action against govt

Firefighters prepare fresh legal action against govt

Firefighter representatives and the Local Government Association have written jointly to the government raising the possibility of legal action if steps are not taken to compensate members affected by the remedy period resulting from the McCloud judgment.

The letter, submitted on April 4 by the LGA on behalf of Fire Rescue Authorities and the Fire Brigades Union, lamented the lack of a solution for members until the expected arrival of legislation in October 2023.

Members affected by the ruling, which found 2015 reforms to the judicial and firefighter pension schemes unlawful on the basis of age discrimination, are said to be those who have taken or are in receipt of benefits prior to the implementation of remedy legislation, which the campaigners said could see them “face an immediate detriment”.

Article continues after advert

The FBU sent the government a similar letter in November 2021 in a bid to stop the cost of the remedy falling on members.

Affected members are preparing legal action

The letter, which was addressed to the Home Office and the Treasury, referred to a framework that had been agreed in October 2021 that would have facilitated payments to FPS members with the aim of compensating for this detriment.

Signed by LGA senior pensions secretary Jo Donnelly and FBU general secretary Matt Wrack, it observed that since the agreement the Treasury has opposed alternative solutions to waiting for the final regulations in 2023.

“This has left FRAs in a position of uncertainty and affected scheme members are actively preparing legal action once again,” the letter stated.

It acknowledged difficulties in the making of some payments, particularly those associated with contributions until clarity had been reached over the relevant tax position.

The letter said claimants in any new proceedings would argue they are entitled to damages “that place them in the same position, net of any tax, that they would have found themselves in if there had been no discriminatory treatment”.

“We do not, however, see any issues with the immediate payment of pension arrears or arrears of lump sum for those within 12 months of leaving and would be grateful for your support in making such payments, in particular, by confirming that such payments will be treated no differently from payments of pension outside of the scope of remedy with regard to funding,” it added.

“Your stance in respect of the position of members who receive payments prior to the implementation of the remedy legislation not being able to be regularised by remedy legislation is unhelpful.”

The letter suggested that existing legislation would allow for “more than adequate flexibility to ensure the regularisation of scheme members benefiting from a considered approach to immediate detriment cases”.

“We do not accept Treasury and Home Office delays in abiding by the decision of the court,” FBU national officer Mark Rowe said.

“There must be no further delays. The FBU legal team are drafting the very significant next round of legal claims which will be registered in the court shortly.”

The government has been contacted for comment.