Defined Benefit  

Getting used to how advising on pension transfers is now done

  • Being brought up to date with the latest thinking on DB transfers
  • Understanding the importance of APTA and TVC
  • Learning how the advice process on DB transfers has changed

This is a real game changer. Transfers are no longer going to be about whether the sum offered by the ceding scheme is good value. They are going to be about whether the shape of DC benefits fit the individual client’s needs better than the DB equivalents.

I believe the answer will often be ‘yes’ and can be demonstrated by a cash flow analysis tool. DB benefits are very back-end loaded. They usually increase, often at rates ahead of today’s low level of inflation. And yet a study by consultancy FinalytiQ proves that pensioner expenditure falls during retirement by around 1 per cent a year in real terms.

Meanwhile, a DC pension can be front-end loaded, taking some cash at outset to pay off any remaining mortgages or loans, to replace a company car or to add a conservatory for those ‘pipe and slipper’ mornings. And then provide a higher pension in the early years of retirement when one is still fit enough for jaunts like taking the grandchildren on holiday.

The APTA is a robust way of demonstrating that a benefit reconstruction is being done to meet agreed client needs. Adviser firms will be responsible for ensuring the APTA is undertaken thoroughly and supports the personal recommendation. 

Advice firms are held liable for the advice, even where it is checked by a third-party pension transfer specialist. Consequently, advisory firms must make sure that any software used in their transfer analysis is supporting their recommendation, not driving it.

The APTA has to look forward. The FCA has woken up to the fact that taking a transfer value is not a point in time decision. It is a commitment to a new way of life, underpinned by an investment and income withdrawal strategy, both of which will require monitoring over time. The APTA must bring both of these into play.

Communication aspects are clearly going to be tricky. The TVC will be conveying a clear ‘don’t do it message’. But it is housed within an over-arching APTA that may say: "We’ve identified your personal needs and found that transferring to DC is the best way of meeting them." Whatever you do, do not take the short-cut favoured by lazy advisers of saying: "This bit is only included to keep the regulator happy". 

Successful advisers will be able to show clients how moving to the much more flexible structure of DC enables the large quantum of wealth tied up in their pension to be deployed in a better manner than the DB scheme was going to. Two further changes will make life more expensive for advisers.


Please answer the six multiple choice questions below in order to bank your CPD. Multiple attempts are available until all questions are correctly answered.

  1. According to Adrian Boulding, which of the following is a significant reason for DB transfer requests being on the increase?

  2. According to Adrian Boulding, what is the ultimate aim of the Transfer Value Comparator?

  3. The FCA is a great believer in critical yield calculations, true or false?

  4. According to Adrian Boulding, what has been the real 'game changer' in DB transfers?

  5. According to Adrian Boulding, advisers are not held liable for advice when the advice is checked by a third-party pension transfer specialist. True or false?

  6. Which of the following will make life more expensive for advisers

Nearly There…

You have successfully answered all the questions correctly, well done!

You should now know…

  • Being brought up to date with the latest thinking on DB transfers
  • Understanding the importance of APTA and TVC
  • Learning how the advice process on DB transfers has changed

I completed this CPD in

To bank your CPD please complete the form below.

Were the stated learning objectives met?

Why weren't they met?

What did you learn from undertaking this CPD exercise?

Why did you undertake this piece of learning?


Congratulations, you have successfully completed and banked this piece of CPD

Already Banked!

You have already banked for this article.

To bank your CPD you must or


One or more questions have been incorrectly answered,
 please review your answers and try again.

Please complete all the above text fields to bank your CPD.

More Pensions CPDSee my completed CPDSee all CPD